USA Weekly
Business

Milburn’s report is perfectly reasonable. It still won’t satisfy Labour backbenchers

Alan Milburn didn’t actually say so during the presentation of his much-anticipated report into youth unemployment, but we just saw the return of the stick.

Milburn’s report is perfectly reasonable. It still won’t satisfy Labour backbenchers

Alan Milburn didn’t actually say so during the presentation of his much-anticipated report into youth unemployment, but we just saw the return of the stick. Welfare reform has been allowed to become such a toxic issue that for decades governments have clung to the idea, publicly at least, that all that benefit claimants need to get back into work is encouragement, support and advice – in other words, the carrot. At last someone has pointed out what was always obvious to mostly everyone in the country: that a life on benefits can too frequently be a comfortable alternative to a life of work, and that there are occasions when people have to be forced, mainly through financial pressure, to do what’s best, rather than what is preferable, for them.

Under the former health secretary’s new master plan, young people currently not in employment, education or training (Neets) would lose welfare payments if they refuse the opportunity of government-subsidised employment support. And there was much else in Milburn’s presentation that will please critics of the current system, even if his gradualist approach will only frustrate those who demand large savings in the short term . Perhaps Milburn’s bravest move was to criticise the NHS, the most sacred of Labour’s sacred cows.

The health system, he said, was not solving the problem of young people who feel physically or mentally unable to take up working or educational opportunities. “Rather than helping young people access help quickly,” he said, “[its treatment model] leads to too many waiting, not working and ending up on welfare. And once people end up on welfare, they find it very hard to get out.” He added: “Poor mental or indeed physical health should not become a one-way route out of education and work.

So we’ve got to stop assuming that just because a young person has anxiety or ADHD, that they cannot work.” Instead, “the health system’s response should be about helping them to earn or learn.” This passage, helpfully, leads us to the heart of the challenge facing Andy Burnham as he seeks to persuade his backbenchers to endorse Milburn’s template for change. The rebellion that saw off the last shreds of Keir Starmer’s authority focused on his plans to cut personal independence payments (PIPs) that looked (and were) basically all about reducing the welfare bill. Milburn’s (and therefore Burnham’s) approach is radically different, demanding that the Government invest even more in employment and education support so that the cost of welfare, if it is to fall, will only happen in the long term.

This is an argument that many of us have been making for some time, specifically that tolerating the long-term unemployment of young people builds up far more difficulties for society further down the line than a high benefits bill – housing costs, health costs, crime costs, as well as the loss of revenue from people who would otherwise be earning and paying tax. That this is a very New Labour argument should not come as a surprise, since Milburn is more New Labour than Tony Blair ever was. That he was chosen to produce such a key policy by this Government is more of a head-scratcher, until you see that the person who appointed him is Pat McFadden, the work and pensions secretary, and one of the few Blairites left on the government benches.

McFadden’s published text to Peter Mandelson, bemoaning the fact that too many of his back-bench colleagues wanted to raise taxes simply to increase benefits, is testament to where he hails from in this debate. Will Burnham now throw his weight behind Milburn and his plan, or will he be tempted, in the face of MPs’ criticisms, to water it down, as he did with Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood’s immigration reforms? Assuming that the Prime Minister’s authority would not withstand another dilution of recommendations that have been so heavily trailed, the next question is whether he can persuade his MPs to legislate for them to come into effect.

For there can be little doubt that the Milburn report will dissatisfy many on both Left and Right and could, at various points between now and full implementation, have few friends and supporters. If Burnham makes the judgment that Milburn’s recommendations, sticks and all, are the right solution to a dreadful problem (one to which no one else has come up with a solution) then he has no option but to demand co-operation from the Parliamentary Labour Party. Few of its members are Blairites these days, but we must hope that there are enough of them who are capable of recognising that a million young people desperately need direct and robust – even expensive – government action to help them live fulfilling lives as workers and tax-payers.

Source: The Telegraph

Distributed to USA Weekly by RedPress.

Related News

Contact Advertise Search RSS